Any education provided to children living in extreme poverty will provide some relevance and benefit. As we know from the US education system, the relevance and benefit received varies greatly from school to school, school district, province, and country. It is my opinion, dollar for dollar, your education dollar goes farther in a developing country.
When an education system produces nursing school directors, hospital administrators, health clinic directors and doctors; it provides relevance and benefit to their rural poor.
The GiveWell Blog - Exploring how to get real change for your dollar. » Developing-world scholarships and school-building.
When you help children in the developing world attend school, what sort of school are you helping them to attend?
The mere construction of a building or provision of a scholarship does not mean that a child is receiving an education. We believe that if you donate to help more children attend school, you must check on the quality and nature of the schools they’re attending - otherwise you could easily be wasting your money.
And even if a child is receiving an education, it’s worth asking whether this education has any real relevance and benefit. Reading and arithmetic skills may open up opportunities in the U.S. (although there is surprisingly little data on whether they do), but do they in rural Africa? Is it realistic or even possible that children who grow up in extreme poverty will find themselves in situations where academic skills are helpful?